Approved Motions of the UTC 105 / L2 202 Joint Meeting
San Jose, CA -- November 1 - 4, 2005
Hosted by Adobe
UTC #105 Agenda
November 10, 2005
[105-C1] Consensus: Approve Draft UTS #37 as a UTS.
[105-C2] Consensus: Accept the property changes for some Old Persian cuneiform characters discussed in L2/05-289 for Unicode 5.0.
[105-C3] Consensus: Accept recommendations 1 through 5 of document L2/05-286.
[105-C4] Consensus: Accept the proposal in L2/05-294 to to change the ALetter definition to tie it to the linebreak property.
[105-C5] Consensus: Adopt the change management for DUCET in doc L2/05-299 (with the provision that the bug database might be separate).
[105-C6] Consensus: Accept items 7 and 8 from document L2/05-286on linebreak defaults and linebreak numbers, changing 7 to be a bullet instead of part of the rule, with other editorial changes suggested in the meeting.
[105-C7] Consensus: Accept A, B, and D of document L2/05-303 regarding "linebfreak=SA" characters.
[105-M1] Motion: Change the script type of U+1DBF to Greek.
Moved by Ken Whistler, Seconded by Rick McGowan
1 against (MS)
2 abstain (RLG, Verisign)
[105-C8] Consensus: Approve the approach in L2/05-277 with the addition that there is no need for an explicit script designator accompanying the registration, with reference to Point 1 in document L2/05-317.
[105-C9] Consensus: The UTC asks the security subcommittee to develop a set of criteria for visual confusability to guide the development of the confusable data tables.
[105-C10] Consensus: Draft UTS #39 should be enhanced to include a discussion of user scenarios and other criteria that were used in the formation of the algorithm and data.
[105-C11] Consensus: Advance Proposed Draft UTS #39 to Draft UTS #39 after incorporating updates as per the meeting.
[105-C12] Consensus: The Security subcommittee is directed to continue its work to enhance the confusable data tables.
[105-C13] Consensus: Recommend to ICANN and the IETF in liaison statements the use of security profiles for identifiers in UTS #39.
[105-C14] Consensus: ICANN guideline 3 (L2/05-363) should be replaced with a requirement for registries to publish the restriction level as defined in UTR #36 by which they operate.
[105-C15] Consensus: ICANN guideline 4 (L2/05-363) should be replaced by language that restricts the permissible characters to those following the security profile for identifiers, currently restricted to the IDN security profile for identifiers.
[105-C16] Consensus: ICANN guideline 5 (L2/05-363) should say: "A registry will define an IDN registration in terms of both its nameprep-normalized Unicode representation and ACE-encoded representation."
[105-C17] Consensus: The last paragraph of ICANN guidelines (L2/05-363) under "Additional Remarks" should be dropped.
[105-C18] Consensus: Update UTR #36 with the recommendations from document L2/05-353 as amended in discussion.
[105-C19] Consensus: Remove U+3003 (the ditto mark) from IDMOD and IDNCHAR in PD UTS #39.
[105-C20] Consensus: UTC approves the direction taken in draft Chapter 3 documented in L2/05-290.
[105-C21] Consensus: Accept four Malayalam characters for encoding in a future version of the standard:
U+0D44 MALAYALAM VOWEL SIGN VOCALIC RR
U+0D62 MALAYALAM VOWEL SIGN VOCALIC L
U+0D3D MALAYALAM PRASLESHAM
U+0D79 MALAYALAM ORDINAL INDICATOR
[105-M2] Motion: Accept the character TIBETAN SIGN RDEL NAG RDEL DKAR in L2/05-345 at U+0FCE for encoding in a future version of the standard. TIBETAN SIGN RDEL NAG RDEL DKAR
Moved by by Eric Muller, seconded by Ken Whistler
2.5 abstain (Basis, Denic, Verisign)
[105-C22] Consensus: Accept TIBETAN MARK NYIS TSHEG for encoding at U+0FD2 in a future version of the standard.
[105-C23] Consensus: Encode the four Alef and Ayin characters for encoding in a future version of the standard at codepoints:
U+A722 LATIN CAPITAL LETTER EGYPTOLOGICAL ALEF
U+A723 LATIN SMALL LETTER EGYPTOLOGICAL ALEF
U+A724 LATIN CAPITAL LETTER EGYPTOLOGICAL AIN
U+A725 LATIN SMALL LETTER EGYPTOLOGICAL AIN
[105-C24] Consensus: Create a PRI on correcting glyphs for Omega with Titlo.
[105-C25] Consensus: Accept the MUSICAL SYMBOL MULTIPLE MEASURE REST at U+1D129 for encoding in a future version of the standard.
[105-C26] Consensus: Create a PRI on the preferred order for 2 combining marks in Gurmukhi.
[105-C27] Consensus: Accept U+0A51 GURMUKHI SIGN UDAAT for encoding with properties as documented in L2/05-344, in a future version of the standard.
[105-C28] Consensus: Create four formal name aliases for Lao character as documented in L2/05-357.
[105-C29] Consensus: Accept the additional characters, name changes, and code changes in code point assignment given in "Part I" of L2/05-270 for Unicode 5.0.
[105-C30] Consensus: Accept U+2E18 INVERTED INTERROBANG for encoding in a future version of the standard.
[105-C31] Consensus: Accept the 48 Ol Chiki characters for encoding at U+1C50..U+1C7F, with block name Ol Chiki U+1C50..U+1C7F for a future version of the standard. (L2/05-243)
[105-C32] Consensus: Accept the 81 Saurashtra characters at U+A880..U+A8DF, with block name Saurashtra U+A880..U+A8DF for encoding in a future version of the standard. (L2/05-222)
[105-M3] Motion: Include the four already-approved Sindhi characters 097B, 097C, 097E, 097F in Version 5.0 of the Unicode Standard. (See doc.)
Moved by Michel Suignard, seconded by Ken Whistler
4 abstain (Sun, Adobe, Denic, Verisign)
[105-C33] Consensus: Designate Mark Davis as the alternate representative of UTC to L2.
[105-C34] Consensus: Accept the four Kannada characters U+0CE2, U+0CE3, U+0CF1, U+0CF2 for encoding in Unicode 5.0, as follows:
0CE2 KANNADA VOWEL SIGN VOCALIC L
0CE3 KANNADA VOWEL SIGN VOCALIC LL
0CF1 KANNADA SIGN JIHVAMULIYA
0CF2 KANNADA SIGN UPADHMANIYA
[105-C35] Consensus: Approve the minutes of UTC 104/L2 201.
[105-C36] Consensus: Change general category to So and linebreak to AL of the characters U+23B4 TOP SQUARE BRACKET, U+23B5 BOTTOM SQUARE BRACKET, U+23B6 TOP AND BOTTOM SQUARE BRACKET.
[105-C37] Consensus: Make changes for items 2, 3, 5 from L2/05-292 as amended in discussion.
[105-C38] Consensus: Authorize the beta of 5.0 to close on January 30, 2006.
[105-C39] Consensus: Give the editorial commmittee the authority to issue proposed updates of any UAX, UTR, or UTS or to issue public review issues for editorial changes.
[105-C40] Consensus: Authorize the editorial committee to refresh public drafts of UAXes, UTSes, UTRs as-needed for editorial changes or for those changes directed by the UTC.
[105-M4] Motion: Revise and extend PRI #80, adding the "starred" characters from document L2/05-362 to the current bidi mirrored property and creating a background document of related characters. Also remove HL6 from UAX #9. The PRI to close on January 30, 2006.
Moved by Mark Davis, seconded by Eric Muller
1.5 against (Basis, Yahoo)
3 abstain (Denic, Sybase, Verisign)
[105-C41] Consensus: The UTC/L2 joint committee expresses its great gratitude to Caty Wissink for her years of excellent leadership and service.