This page is a compilation of formal public feedback received so far. See Feedback for further information on this issue, how to discuss it, and how to provide feedback.
Date/Time: Sun Nov 19 22:58:00 CST 2017
Report Type: Public Review Issue
Opt Subject: Feedback on PRI #363
The example in 2.2 "⿺辶才 (UAX #45 UTC-00339) versus ⿺辶言 (U+9019 這)" is not a good example because (1) the graphical difference is extremely significant and (2) it was not discussed by IRG. The example in 2.2 "⿲糹𡝤鳥 (UAX #45 UTC-00185) versus ⿰縷鳥 (U+2A21C 𪈜)" is not a good example because it is unifiable according to UCV Rule 348. Some other cases which were considered for IVD, but rejected by the member bodies in the time frame for WS2015 include: T13-3132 ⿺𠃊屲 (to be encoded in Extension G) versus U+5EF6 延 T13-3135 ⿺𠃊聿 (to be encoded in Extension G) versus U+5EFA 建 GHZR42149.16 ⿰⿱矛示毛 (to be encoded in Extension G) versus U+23BAA 𣮪 The consensus in IRG that the reduction of variants would take place in WS2017 and not apply to WS2015. Therefore, even though these cases are encoded for WS2015, they could be considered for unification/IVD in WS2017.