L2/16-325

Draft Minutes of UTC Meeting 149
San José, CA -- November 1-4, 2016
Hosted by IBM
UTC #149 Agenda
Revision date: November 15, 2016

Monday, November 7, 2016

Meeting opened at 10:40.

6.5 members represented: Adobe, Apple, Google, IBM, Microsoft, UCB, EmojiXpress

Quorum = 4.5.

A.5.2.1 Review of open action items [L2/SD2]

Oral review.

E.1.12 Hijab/Headscarf emoji [Alhumedhi, Lee, et al, L2/16-284]

Oral presentation by authors.

B.14.4 Handling interaction between UCD and emoji properties [Davis, L2/16-315]

[149-A1] Action Item for Lisa Moore: Add document L2/16-315 to the agenda for the January 2017 UTC meeting.

E.1.24 Remove multi-person emoji from Emoji_Modifier_Base [Edberg, Davis, et al, L2/16-332]

Lunch break at 12:07 - 12:15

B.11.1 Issue 329: Proposed Update UAX #44, Unicode Character Database
B.11.1.1.1 General feedback [L2/16-327]

[149-A2] Action Item for Ken Whistler: Incorporate feedback from Ken Lunde on UAX #44 in L2/16-327 for Unicode version 10.0.

B.11.1.1.2 Suggestions for UCD in version 10.0 [Lettvin, L2/16-344]

[149-A3] Action Item for Rick McGowan, Ken Whistler: Reply to Jonathan Lettvin, to look in PropertyValueAliases.txt, etc, for property names.

[149-A4] Action Item for Rick McGowan: Extend the closing date of PRI #329 to January 16, 2017.

B.11.4 Issue 332: Proposed Update UTS #10, Unicode Collation
B.11.4.1.1 General feedback [L2/16-327]
B.11.4.1.2 Newline characters should map to a completely ignorable collation element in the DUCET [Lodewijck, L2/16-301]
B.11.4.1.3 Request to change the level 4 weights in the CTT [Lodewijck, L2/16-323]
B.11.4.2 Document for review [Scherer, L2/16-348]

[149-A5] Action Item for Markus Scherer: Review second feedback from Marc Lodewijck in PRI #332 and documents L2/16-323 and L2/16-301, and make recommendations.

[149-A6] Action Item for Rick McGowan: Extend the closing date of PRI #332 to January 16, 2017.

B.11.5 Issue 333: Proposed Update UTR #31, Unicode Identifier and Pattern Syntax
B.11.5.1.1 General feedback [L2/16-327]
B.11.5.2 Document for review [Davis, L2/16-349]

[149-A7] Action Item for Mark Davis, Editorial Committee: Add clarifications to proposed update UAX #31 based on feedback from Jonathan Warden.

[149-A8] Action Item for Rick McGowan: Respond to Jonathan Warden, re disposition of feedback on PRI #333.

[149-A9] Action Item for Rick McGowan: Extend the closing date of PRI #333 to January 16, 2017.

B.11.6 Issue 334: Proposed Update UTS #39, Unicode Security Mechanisms
B.11.6.1.1 General feedback [L2/16-327]
B.11.6.2 Document for review [Davis, L2/16-350]

[149-A10] Action Item for Mark Davis, Editorial Committee: Make appropriate changes suggested by Gervase Markham for PRI #334 in UTS #39.

[149-A11] Action Item for Rick McGowan: Respond to Gervase Markham on PRI #334.

B.11.8 Issue 336: Proposed Update UAX #41, Common References for Unicode Standard Annexes
B.11.8.1.1 General feedback [L2/16-327]
B.11.8.2 Document for review [McGowan, Iancu, L2/16-352]

Discussion. UTC took no action at this time.

D.4 Changes to Gurmukhi 10 [Singh, L2/16-294]
D.4.1 Feedback on L2/16-294 on Gurmukhi [Sharma, L2/16-302]

[149-A12] Action Item for Rick McGowan, Paul Hunt, Ken Whistler, Michel Suignard: Get a font showing an alternative Gurmukhi glyph for Yakash U+A075 in accordance with L2/16-294, so it shows up in the charts.

[149-A13] Action Item for Rick McGowan: Consult with Ken Whistler and respond to Manvir Singh, re public feedback in L2/16-327 regarding L2/16-294 (Gurmukhi); supplying info from the above decision.

B.11.9.1.1 General feedback [L2/16-327]

[149-A14] Action Item for Mark Davis, Laurențiu Iancu: Correct the header of DerivedBidiClass.txt for Unicode 10.0 based on feedback from Eric Muller in L2/16-327.

[149-A15] Action Item for Deborah Anderson: Add feedback in L2/16-327 from Norbert Lindenberg to script ad hoc agenda.

[149-A16] Action Item for Rick McGowan: Respond to Norbert Lindenberg re feedback disposition in L2/16-327.

[149-A17] Action Item for Ken Whistler: Fix typo in names list, based on feedback from Marcel Schneider in L2/16-327.

[149-A18] Action Item for Rick McGowan: Respond to Marcel Schneider re typo fix feedback in L2/16-327.

[149-A19] Action Item for Ken Whistler: Review Kamal Mansour's error report in L2/16-327 and fix if appropriate.

On Phone: Judy Safran-Aasen (Microsoft)

E.1.9 Proposal for person meditating emoji [Bramhill, L2/16-279]

Discussion with oral presentation by author. UTC took no action at this time.

B.11.2 Issue 330: Proposed Update UTR #51, Unicode Emoji
B.11.2.1.1 General feedback [L2/16-327]
B.11.2.2 Document for review [Davis, Edberg, L2/16-346]

[149-A20] Action Item for Mark Davis, Peter Edberg: Move the selected product table and the Japanese carrier emoji diagram out of UTR #51 into the emoji area on the website.

[149-A21] Action Item for Rick McGowan: Respond to William Overington that UTC took no action on his feedback of August 15 to PRI #330.

[149-A22] Action Item for Rick McGowan: Respond to Kennedy Stomps feedback on PRI #330, that the names have been fixed and will appear in an update.

[149-A23] Action Item for Rick McGowan: Respond to Cristoph Päper on August 12 feedback that UTC declines to take any action on PRI #330 feedback. See L2/16-327.

[149-A24] Action Item for Rick McGowan: Respond to Cristoph Päper on August 26 feedback. See L2/16-327.

[149-A25] Action Item for Rick McGowan: Respond to Patrick O'Toole feedback of October 11 that this was taken care of in Unicode version 9. See L2/16-327.

[149-A26] Action Item for Rick McGowan: Respond to Camila Miyamura's feedback of October 19 that all proposals for emoji must follow the documented process. See L2/16-327.

[149-A27] Action Item for Rick McGowan: Respond to William Overington's questions of October 24 in L2/16-327.

E.1.23 Process for Emoji ZWJ Sequence Proposals [ESC/Burge, L2/16-320]

[149-C1] Consensus: Put together a definitive list of recommended ZWJ sequences, after the publication of UTR #51 version 4.0.

[149-A28] Action Item for Mark Davis, Peter Edberg, Emoji Subcommittee: Convert the catalog for 4.0 into the recommended lists of ZWJ sequences.

[149-A29] Action Item for Mark Davis, Peter Edberg, Emoji Subcommittee: Create a process for creating new ZWJ sequences.

Short break.

B.11.3 Issue 331: Proposed Update UTR #50, Unicode Vertical Text Layout
B.11.3.1.1 General feedback [L2/16-327]
B.11.3.2 Document for review [Ishii, Iancu, L2/16-347]

[149-C2] Consensus: Approve revision 17 of UTR #50 for publication.

[149-A30] Action Item for Rick McGowan: Make revision 17 of UTR #50 live as the published version.

[149-A31] Action Item for Rick McGowan: Close PRI #331.

B.12.2 UAX #50, Unicode Vertical Text Layout
B.12.2.1 Working Draft of Proposed Update UAX #50, Unicode Vertical Text Layout [Iancu, L2/16-359]

[149-A32] Action Item for Rick McGowan: Post a PRI for proposed update UAX #50 to close January 16, 2017.

[149-A33] Action Item for Laurențiu Iancu, Koji Ishii: Prepare the data file for PU UAX #50.

[149-A34] Action Item for Ken Whistler, Editorial Committee: Update the text of UAX #44 for the implications of making UAX #50 an annex.

[149-A35] Action Item for Mark Davis, Laurențiu Iancu: Update PropertyAliases.txt and PropertyValueAliases.txt to include VerticalOrientation.

[149-A36] Action Item for Eric Muller, Editorial Committee: Add VerticalOrientation to UAX #42.

[149-A37] Action Item for Mark Davis, Andy Heninger, Editorial Committee: Synchronize the properties of UTS #18 with UAX #44 version 10.

D.3 Proposal to encode the TELUGU SIGN COMBINING ANUSVARA ABOVE [Srinidhi, Sridatta, L2/16-285]

[149-C3] Consensus: Accept U+0C04 TELUGU SIGN COMBINING ANUSVARA ABOVE for encoding in a future version of the standard. See document L2/17-285.

[149-A38] Action Item for Ken Whistler: Add U+0C04 TELUGU SIGN COMBINING ANUSVARA ABOVE to the pipeline.

[149-A39] Action Item for Deborah Anderson: Add U+0C04 TELUGU SIGN COMBINING ANUSVARA ABOVE to document requesting future additions.

[149-A40] Action Item for Rick McGowan: Get a font for U+0C04 TELUGU SIGN COMBINING ANUSVARA ABOVE. // Grab from existing font and stuff.

E.9 Eris and Sedna Symbols [Faulks, L2/16-173]

Discussion. UTC took no action at this time.

E.1.11 Emoji glyph updates [ESC/Burge, Hunt, L2/16-281]

[149-C4] Consensus: Update the Unicode Standard code charts in accordance with the recommendations of L2/16-281, for Unicode 10.0.

[149-A41] Action Item for Paul Hunt, Rick McGowan, Michel Suignard: Update code chart glyphs based on L2/16-281, for Unicode 10.0.

E.1.27 Summary of proposed 10.0 emoji (PDF snapshot) [ESC/Edberg, L2/16-355]

Discussion. UTC took no action at this time.

Meeting adjourned for the day at 5:20 pm.

Tuesday, November 8, 2016

6.5 members represented: Adobe, Apple, IBM, Microsoft, UCB, EmojiXpress, Google

B.1.1.4 Consent docket [Whistler, L2/16-276]

[149-C5] Consensus: Accept the new codepoints for 13 astrological symbols as documented in L2/16-276:

	U+2BD4 → U+2BD3  PLUTO FORM TWO
	U+2BD5 → U+2BD4  PLUTO FORM THREE
	U+2BD6 → U+2BD5  PLUTO FORM FOUR
	U+2BD7 → U+2BD6  PLUTO FORM FIVE
	U+2BE8 → U+2BD7  TRANSPLUTO
	U+2BE9 → U+2BD8  PROSERPINA
	U+2BF0 → U+2BD9  ASTRAEA
	U+2BF1 → U+2BDA  HYGIEA
	U+2BF2 → U+2BDB  PHOLUS
	U+2BF3 → U+2BDC  NESSUS
	U+2BF4 → U+2BDD  WHITE MOON SELENA
	U+2BF5 → U+2BDE  BLACK DIAMOND ON CROSS
	U+2BF6 → U+2BDF  TRUE LIGHT MOON ARTA

[149-C6] Consensus: Accept four half-star symbols U+2BE8 and U+2BEB for encoding in a future version of the standard, as documented in L2/16-298 / L2/16-254:

	U+2BE8 LEFT HALF BLACK STAR
	U+2BE9 RIGHT HALF BLACK STAR
	U+2BEA STAR WITH LEFT HALF BLACK
	U+2BEB STAR WITH RIGHT HALF BLACK

[149-C7] Consensus: Move two kana letters and accept 285 hentaigana characters in a new Kana Extended-A block, for encoding in a future version of the standard, as documented in L2/16-298.

Note: 1B002..1B0FF: 254 hentaigana in the existing Kana Supplement block
1B100..1B11E: 31 hentaigana in a new Kana Extended-A block: 1B100..1B12F

[149-C8] Consensus: Accept 30 Xiangqi game symbols as documented in L2/176-298 and section F of L2/16-276 for encoding in a future version of the standard.

[149-C9] Consensus: Accept the changes for Mongolian StandardizedVariants.txt for a future version of the standard, as documented in section G of L2/16-276.

(Ed Note: the above consensus 149-C9 was rescinded on Thursday, see below.)

[149-A42] Action Item for Ken Whistler: Update the pipeline for changes driven by the consent docket (5 consensi above).

B.2.1.3 Liaison report from OWG Sort Editor [Whistler]

Oral report from Ken Whistler.

B.9 Unicode Locales Project (CLDR)
B.9.1 Liaison report [Davis, Edberg]

Oral report from Mark Davis.

Short break.

B.11.7 Issue 335: Proposed Update UAX #14, Unicode Line Breaking Algorithm
B.11.7.1.1 General feedback [L2/16-327]
B.11.7.2 Document for review [Heninger, L2/16-351]

Andy Heninger now present.

[149-A43] Action Item for Andy Heninger: Work with Mark Davis and Laurențiu Iancu to create a response to feedback from Swaran Lata on UAX #14. See L2/16-327 and PRI #335 feedback.

[149-A43a] Action Item for Andy Heninger, Editorial Committee: Make fixes to text of UAX #14 based on discussion and update the Proposed Update draft for 10.0.

[149-A44] Action Item for Rick McGowan: Extend the closing date of PRI #335 to January 16, 2017.

B.12.3.1 Working Draft of Proposed Update UAX #9, Unicode Bidirectional Algorithm [Iancu, L2/16-366]

[149-A45] Action Item for Laurențiu Iancu, Editorial Committee: Prepare a proposed update of UAX #9 for Unicode 10.0 based on document L2/16-366.

[149-A46] Action Item for Rick McGowan: Post the PRI for UAX #9 to close January 16, 2017.

Further discussion of reference implementation.

[149-A47] Action Item for Mark Davis, Laurențiu Iancu: Update the Java Bidi part of the Unicode tools from 7.0 to 9.0.

B.14.7 A Proposed DerivedName.txt File for the UCD [Iancu, L2/16-335]

[149-C10] Consensus: Add a file called DerivedName.txt to the "extracted" subdirectory of the UCD for version 10.0, for the Name property, with format and content as documented in L2/16-335.

[149-A48] Action Item for Laurențiu Iancu, Mark Davis: Update the derivation part of UCD tools to produce "DerivedName.txt" as part of UCD releases.

[149-A49] Action Item for Ken Whistler, Editorial Committee: Update UAX #44 for addition of the "DerivedName.txt" file.

B.14.8 Candidate Characters for Word_Break = ALetter [Iancu, L2/16-336]

[149-A50] Action Item for Andy Heninger: Review cases where LineBreak and WordBreak are not aligned, for the January 2017 UTC meeting. See L2/16-336.

[149-A51] Action Item for Laurențiu Iancu, Mark Davis, Editorial Committee: Update UAX #29 text with the property change for L2/16-336.

Lunch and emoji ad hoc 11:55 - 1:20.

B.14.4 Handling interaction between UCD and emoji properties [Davis, L2/16-315R]

[149-C11] Consensus: Adopt solution C in L2/16-315R for dealing with the asynchronous development of UCD and emoji properties, in Unicode 10.0.

[149-A52] Action Item for Mark Davis, Laurențiu Iancu, Editorial Committee: Review and modify the proposed update of UAX #29 for Unicode 10.0 to make it consistent with approach C of L2/16-315R.

[149-A53] Action Item for Andy Heninger, Editorial Committee: Review and modify the proposed update of UAX #14 for Unicode 10.0 to make it consistent with approach C of L2/16-315R.

[149-A54] Action Item for Ken Whistler, Editorial Committee: Update UAX #44 for Unicode 10.0 to note the handling of the dependency on emoji properties. See L2/16-315R.

[149-A55] Action Item for Mark Davis, Peter Edberg: Create a new data file, EmojiVariationSequences.txt, for UTR #51 version 5.0 with the contents being the emoji variation sequences from StandardizedVariants.txt plus the sequences listed under ED-9 in UTR #51 version 4.0.

[149-A56] Action Item for Ken Whistler, Editorial Committee: Update the section on variation sequences in the core spec for Unicode 10.0 to account for option C of L2/16-315R.

B.14.10 Proposal to add formal aliases to U+11EC through U+11EF [Chung, L2/16-363]

[149-C12] Consensus: Create four named aliases for 11EC through 11EF, as documented in secction 1 page 7 of L2/16-363, for Unicode 10.0:

	11EC;HANGUL JONGSEONG YESIEUNG-KIYEOK;correction
	11ED;HANGUL JONGSEONG YESIEUNG-SSANGKIYEOK;correction
	11EE;HANGUL JONGSEONG SSANGYESIEUNG;correction
	11EF;HANGUL JONGSEONG YESIEUNG-KHIEUKH;correction

[149-A57] Action Item for Ken Whistler: Update NameAliases.txt for 11EC through 11EF as documented in L2/16-363, for Unicode 10.0. See above consensus 149-C19.

[149-A58] Action Item for Deborah Anderson: Add four named aliases for 11EC through 11EF, as documented in section 1 page 7 of L2/16-363 to document requesting future additions.

Short break.

B.11.2 Issue 330: Proposed Update UTR #51, Unicode Emoji
B.11.2.1.1 General feedback [L2/16-327]
B.11.2.1.2 ESC comments on PRI 300 feedback [Edberg, L2/16-356]
B.11.2.2 Document for review [Davis, Edberg, L2/16-346]

Discussion. There will be an ad hoc meeting, Wednesday 12:00.

E.1.24 Remove multi-person emoji from Emoji_Modifier_Base [Edberg, Davis, et al, L2/16-332]

[149-C13] Consensus: Remove the 7 characters documented in L2/16-332 from Emoji_Modifier_Base, for the beta version of Emoji 4.0, including a change of two characters from Emoji 3.0 (U+1F93C Wrestlers and U+1F91D Handshake).

[149-A59] Action Item for Peter Edberg, Mark Davis, Editorial Committee: Update Emoji-Data.txt and the text of UTR #51, and the emoji charts to remove the 7 characters documented in L2/16-332 from Emoji_Modifier_Base for Emoji version 4.0.

E.1.27 Summary of proposed 10.0 emoji (PDF snapshot) [ESC/Edberg, L2/16-355]

Discussion.

3:10 p.m. Plenary session moved to another room temporarily.

6 members present: Adobe, Apple (proxy), IBM, Microsoft, Google (proxy), UCB.

C.14 Kana
C.14.1 Hiragana and Katakana (Small Letters) [Sim, L2/16-334]
C.14.2 Proposal to add Kana small letters [Yamaguchi, L2/16-354]
C.14.3 L2/16-334 & L2/16-354 Feedback (small kana) [Lunde, L2/16-358]

[149-C14] Consensus: Move HIRAGANA LETTER SMALL KO to U+1B127 and KATAKANA LETTER SMALL KO to U+1B128. And approve 7 small Kana U+1B129 - U+1B12F for encoding in a future version of the standard:

	U+1B129 HIRAGANA LETTER SMALL WI
	U+1B12A HIRAGANA LETTER SMALL WE
	U+1B12B HIRAGANA LETTER SMALL WO
	U+1B12C KATAKANA LETTER SMALL WI
	U+1B12D KATAKANA LETTER SMALL WE
	U+1B12E KATAKANA LETTER SMALL WO
	U+1B12F KATAKANA LETTER SMALL N

[149-A60] Action Item for Ken Whistler: Update the pipeline to include 7 small Kana U+1B129 - U+1B12F, as in above consenus 149-C14.

[149-A61] Action Item for Deborah Anderson: Add 7 small Kana U+1B129 - U+1B12F to document requesting future additions. Add request to move two small kana that are already in ballot.

[149-A62] Action Item for Ken Lunde: Reply to submitters of L2/16-334 and L2/16-354.

[149-A63] Action Item for Ken Lunde: Supply a font for all 9 newly encoded small kana to Michel Suignard.

C.8 Mayan Questions [Quinn, L2/16-264]

[149-C15] Consensus: Accept 20 Mayan Numerals 1D2E0..1D2F3, with block "Mayan Numerals" at 1D2E0..1D2FF, as documented in L2/16-264, for encoding in a future version of the standard.

[149-A64] Action Item for Ken Whistler: Update the pipeline to include 20 Mayan Numerals. See L2/16-264.

[149-A65] Action Item for Deborah Anderson: Add 20 Mayan Numerals to document requesting future additions. See L2/16-264.

[149-A66] Action Item for Deborah Anderson: Get a font for 20 Mayan Numerals. See L2/16-264.

[149-A67] Action Item for Deborah Anderson: Work with author of L2/16-264 to get an update.

D.13 Proposal to encode CHAKMA LETTER LHAA, DEPENDENT VOWEL SIGNS AA & EI for Chakma [Chakma, Glass, L2/16-330]

[149-C16] Consensus: Accept three Chakma characters for encoding in Unicode version 11.0, with properties as documented in L2/16-330:

	U+11144 CHAKMA LETTER LHAA
	U+11145 CHAKMA VOWEL SIGN AA
	U+11146 CHAKMA VOWEL SIGN EI

[149-A68] Action Item for Ken Whistler: Update the pipeline to include three Chakma letters. See L2/16-330.

[149-A69] Action Item for Deborah Anderson: Add three Chakma letters to document requesting future additions. See L2/16-330.

[149-A70] Action Item for Andrew Glass: Provide a font for 3 new Chakma letters to Michel Suignard. See L2/16-330.

Plenary session returned to main meeting room.

B.3.1 IRG Liaison report [Lunde, L2/16-287]

Oral report from Ken Lunde.

B.4.1 Forty-one kCangjie values to be added and one kCangjie value to be corrected [Chung, L2/16-237]

[149-A71] Action Item for John Jenkins: Add the 41 kCangjie values to Unihan for version 10.0, based on L2/16-237.

B.4.3 Unihan 9.0 (kHanyuPinyin, kMandarin) Errata [Cook, et al, L2/16-246]

[149-A72] Action Item for John Jenkins, Richard Cook: Review L2/16-246 and fix inconsistencies, and submit a revised version.

B.4.2 Proposal of urgently needed characters (revised) [Fan, L2/16-239R]

[149-A73] Action Item for John Jenkins: Add characters in L2/16-239R to proposed update for UAX #45, and include in our submission for Extension H. See L2/16-239R.

B.4.4 Report on 〇 and two ideographs [Jenkins, L2/16-269]

[149-A74] Action Item for John Jenkins: Add character Hanyu Dazidian 42326.100 to proposed update of UAX #45, and include in our submission for Extension H. See L2/16-269.

B.4.5 Proposed additions to UAX #45 [Jenkins, L2/16-286] B.4.5.1 Analysis of proposed additions to UAX #45 [West, L2/16-290]

Discussion. UTC took no action at this time.

B.4.6 Request to redefine the scope of the Ideographic Variation Database [West, L2/16-291]

[149-C17] Consensus: Change the scope of ideographic variation sequences so that the base is not defined by the unified ideograph property, but rather consist of the set of ideographs that are neither canonical nor compatibility decomposable.

[149-A75] Action Item for Ken Whistler, Editorial Committee: Update the definition of ideographic variation sequences in the core spec for version 10.0. See L2/16-291.

[149-A76] Action Item for Ken Lunde, Editorial Committee: Prepare a proposed update of UTS #37, changing the scope of valid base characters. See L2/16-291.

[149-A77] Action Item for Rick McGowan: Post the PRI for UTS #37 to close January 16, 2017. See L2/16-291.

[149-A78] Action Item for Ken Lunde: Update the landing page for the IVD. See L2/16-291.

[149-A79] Action Item for Ken Lunde: Respond to Andrew West re disposition of L2/16-291.

A.6 Calendar review

Schedule: Q4 2017 UTC meeting, preferred dates: Oct 30-Nov 2, tentatively hosted by Apple. Try for IUC conference Oct 23 - 25 (M-W).

Adjourned for the day at 5:20.

Wednesday, November 9, 2016

Meeting opened at 10:30 am.

6.5 members represented: Adobe, Apple, Google, IBM, Microsoft, UCB, EmojiXpress

B.14.3 Script property of Arabic Letter Mark and interaction with digit substitution mechanisms [Constable, L2/16-306]

[149-A80] Action Item for Lisa Moore: Add L2/16-306 to the January 2017 UTC meeting agenda.

B.14.6 Dependency Graph for Segmentation [Davis, Iancu, L2/16-328]

Discussion. UTC took no action at this time.

E.9 Eris and Sedna Symbols [Faulks, L2/16-173]

[149-C18] Consensus: Accept three characters: U+2BBA ERIS FORM ONE, U+2BBB ERIS FORM TWO, U+2BBC SEDNA with properties as given in L2/16-173 for encoding in a future version of the standard.

[149-A81] Action Item for Ken Whistler: Update the pipeline to include U+2BBA ERIS FORM ONE, U+2BBB ERIS FORM TWO, U+2BBC SEDNA.

[149-A82] Action Item for Deborah Anderson: Add U+2BBA ERIS FORM ONE, U+2BBB ERIS FORM TWO, U+2BBC SEDNA to the document requesting future additions.

E.10 Extra Aspect Symbols for Astrology [Faulks, L2/16-174]

[149-C19] Consensus: Accept 6 symbols at U+1BF0..U+1BF5 with names and codepoints L2/16-342, and properties as in L2/16-174:

	2BF0 QUINTILE
	2BF1 TREDECILE
	2BF2 NOVILE
	2BF3 BINOVILE
	2BF4 CENTILE
	2BF5 VIGINTILE

for encoding in a future version of the standard.

[149-A83] Action Item for Ken Whistler: Update the pipeline to include 6 astrological aspect signs. See above consensus 149-C19 and L2/16-174, L2/16-342.

[149-A84] Action Item for Deborah Anderson: Add 6 astrological aspect signs to the document requesting future additions.

[149-A85] Action Item for Deborah Anderson: Relay feedback to David Faulks on L2/16-174 and request an updated document. See above consensus 149-C19 and L2/16-174, L2/16-342.

E.7 A proposal to encode Creative Commons license and public domain icons in UCS [Creative Commons/Park, L2/16-283]

[149-A86] Action Item for Alolita Sharma, Rick McGowan: Follow up on the Creative Commons icons with questions from the committee. See L2/16-283.

Lunch break and ad hoc, 11:45 - 1:15.

B.14.2 Request to change the Indic Shaping Property for U+11134 [Glass, Chakma, L2/16-303]

[149-A87] Action Item for Ken Whistler: Add an annotation to U+11134 for Unicode 10.0.

B.14.9 Add text and emoji standardized variation sequences for 96 symbols [Pournader, L2/16-361]

[149-A88] Action Item for Mark Davis, Peter Edberg: Add the list of 96 symbols in document L2/16-361 to EmojiVariationSequencers.txt for Unicode 10.0.

B.11.4 Issue 332: Proposed Update UTS #10, Unicode Collation
B.11.4.1.1 General feedback [L2/16-327]

[149-A89] Action Item for Markus Scherer: Investigate the second error report in PRI #332 feedback, and fix the generator code and data file if appropriate.

B.11.4.1.2 Newline characters should map to a completely ignorable collation element in the DUCET [Lodewijck, L2/16-301]

[149-A90] Action Item for Markus Scherer: Respond to author of L2/16-301 that UTC took no action on the document.

B.11.4.1.3 Request to change the level 4 weights in the CTT [Lodewijck, L2/16-323]

[149-A91] Action Item for Ken Whistler: Respond to author of L2/16-323, and make fixes to CTT table generation.

B.12.1 UAX #29, Unicode Text Segmentation
B.12.1.1 Working Draft of Proposed Update UAX #29, Unicode Text Segmentation [Davis, et al, L2/16-360]

[149-A92] Action Item for Rick McGowan: Post a PRI for proposed update of UAX #29 based on L2/16-360, to close January 16, 2017.

B.11.2 Issue 330: Proposed Update UTR #51, Unicode Emoji
B.11.2.3 Results from ad hoc on ZWJ sequences [Davis, L2/16-368]

[149-A93] Action Item for Mark Davis, Peter Edberg, Editorial Committee: Make changes to UTR #51 based on L2/16-368.

Mouse now present. 6.502 members represented.

[149-A94] Action Item for Landlord: Capture and exile the mouse that just fell out of the light fixture.

[149-C20] Consensus: Approve the publication of UTR #51 version 4.0, as amended in discussion, with associated data files.

[149-A95] Action Item for Mark Davis, Peter Edberg, Editorial Committee: Prepare UTR #51 version 4.0 documentation for publication.

[149-A96] Action Item for Rick McGowan: Close PRI #330.

[149-A97] Action Item for Rick McGowan, Editorial Committee: Publish UTR #51 version 4.0 documentation and data.

E.1.27 Summary of proposed 10.0 emoji (PDF snapshot) [ESC/Edberg, L2/16-355]
E.1.32 Response to 2016Q4 feedback on encoding proposals [Davis, Edberg, L2/16-364]

[149-A98] Action Item for Rick McGowan: Respond to commenters, pointing to L2/16-364.

Short break.

B.12.4 UTS #52, Unicode Emoji Mechanisms
B.12.4.1 Reactivating UTS #52 Mechanism in UTR #51 [Edberg, Davis, et al, L2/16-226R]

[149-A99] Action Item for Mark Davis, Peter Edberg, Editorial Committee: Include material based on L2/16-226R excluding the discussion of private use, and modifying the syntax and discussion to only allow empty keys. For the proposed update UTR #51 version 5.0.

[149-A100] Action Item for Rick McGowan: Post PRI for PU UTR #51 version 5.0, to close January 16, 2017.

[149-A101] Action Item for Ken Whistler, Editorial Committee: Change the status of Proposed Draft UTS #52 from "Suspended" to "Withdrawn".

E.1.26 Emoji Subcommittee Terminology and Process [ESC/Edberg, L2/16-337]

Discussion. UTC took no action at this time.

E.3 Proposal to encode an Ichthys symbol (WG2 N4746) [West, L2/16-253]

Discussion. UTC took no action at this time.

E.2 Proposal to encode an Indalo symbol (WG2 N4745) [West, L2/16-252]

Discussion. UTC took no action at this time.

E.8 Proposal to Encode Heterodox Chess Symbols [Wallace, L2/16-293]

[149-A102] Action Item for Deborah Anderson: Respond to Garth Wallace re the proposal Heterodox Chess symbols.

C.11.1 Suggestions on some Al-Dani Quranic Marks proposition [Lazrek, L2/16-268]

Discussion. UTC took no action at this time.

C.13 pIqaD (Klingon) and its usage [Shoulson, L2/16-329]

[149-A103] Action Item for Rick McGowan: Respond to submitter that it looks like there is sufficient usage to justify encoding Klingon as a script. UTC would need clear proof that Paramount would not pursue legal action against the Unicode Consortium, or anyone who implements the script.

C.6 Preliminary Proposal for encoding Primitive Scripts in Southwest China in the SMP [Zhao, L2/16-262]
C.7 Updated proposal for encoding Shuishu in the SMP [China NB, L2/16-263]

Discussion. UTC took no action at this time.

Meeting adjourned at 5:26.

Thursday, November 10, 2016

Meeting opened at 9:36 am.

6.002 members represented: Adobe, Apple, Google, IBM, Microsoft, UCB, Mouse

C.5.6 Proposed additions for Mongolian in 5th edition of UCS [Zhuang, L2/16-309]
C.5.4 Comments on the Mongolian block [Zheng, L2/16-292]

[149-C21] Consensus: Rescind Consensus 149-C9 on Mongolian Standardized Variants.

[149-A104] Action Item for Deborah Anderson: Relay feedback on Mongolian discussion to Greg Eck and Chen Zhuang.

[149-A104a] Action Item for Ken Whistler: Update pipeline to remove additions for Mongolian standardized variation sequences.

B.13.3.1 Content of V10.0

[149-C22] Consensus: Include three already-approved Zanabazar Square Characters, U+11A45..U+11A47 in Unicode version 10.0.

E.1.27.1 Summary of proposed 10.0 emoji (PDF snapshot) [ESC/Edberg, L2/16-369]

[149-C23] Consensus: Accept 51 characters as document in L2/16-369 for encoding in Unicode version 10.0.

[149-A105] Action Item for Ken Whistler: Add 51 emoji characters to the pipeline, as documented in L2/16-369.

[149-A106] Action Item for Deborah Anderson: Add 51 emoji characters to the pipeline, as documented in L2/16-369, to document requesting future additions.

[149-A107] Action Item for Paul Hunt: Supply a font for new emoji characters to Michel Suignard, by November 30, 2016.

[149-A108] Action Item for Mark Davis, Peter Edberg, Emoji Subcommittee: Update the emoji candidates page.

C.15.1 Georgian language ad-hoc report (WG 4774) [Loomis, L2/16-339]
C.15.2 Georgian Minister of Education and Science support for "Mtavruli" encoding proposal [Everson L2/16-353]

Michael Everson on the phone.

Discussion. UTC took no action at this time.

Lunch 11:45 - 12:30.

C.3.7 Discussion of Cluster Formation in Khitan Small Script (WG2 N4775) [West, Everson, et al, L2/16-296]

Discussion. UTC took no action at this time.

E.6 Proposal to encode additional circled numbers [West, L2/16-256]

Discussion. UTC took no action at this time.

C.10 Preliminary proposal to encode Proto-Cuneiform in the SMP (WG2 N4760) [SEI/Everson, Hawkins, L2/16-267]

Discussion. UTC took no action at this time.

D.2 Preliminary proposal to encode Tigalari script [Murthy, L2/16-241]

[149-A109] Action Item for Deborah Anderson: Relay script ad hoc feedback to author of L2/16-241.

B.13.3.1 Content of V10.0

[149-C24] Consensus: The repertoire of Unicode 10.0 will be synchronized with the new repertoire in ISO 10646 5th edition, 3 Zanabazar Square characters, 56 emoji additions and 285 hentaigana characters.

[149-A110] Action Item for Michel Suignard: Provide the delta nameslist for the 10646 5th edition to Ken Whistler, including the hentaigana list.

[149-A111] Action Item for Lisa Moore: Add the following items from the current agenda to the agenda for the next UTC meeting (Q12017) - B14.5, B.14.1, E.1.25, E.1.21

		B.14.5 Emoji RI property [Davis, L2/16-319]
		B.14.1 Adding EmojiDefective property [Davis, Edberg, et al, L2/16-238R]
		E.1.25 SELFIE with people/gender [Edberg, Davis, et al, L2/16-333]
		E.1.21 Proposal to enable gender inclusive emoji representation [Hunt, L2/16-317] (particularly "Mercury symbol")

B.1.1.3 IR's meeting report [Anderson, L2/16-278]

Oral report from Deborah Anderson.

B.10 Unicode Localization Interoperability (ULI)
B.10.1 Liaison report [Loomis, L2/16-367]

Oral report from Steven Loomis.

B.1.6 Review of document requesting new additions [Anderson, L2/16-370]

Meeting adjourned at 2:33 pm.

Mouse still at large.

L2 meeting continued.

UTC Attendance

Members Represented

Members not in regular attendance: Bangladesh, India, Tamil Nadu, Monotype, Oracle, SAP

Total full members in regular attendance: 6

Total institutional members in regular attendance: 2

Total supporting members in regular attendance: 1

Quorum: 4.5