From: Andy White (Andy__White@btinternet.com)
Date: Sat Mar 01 2003 - 15:53:33 EST
I think that one of my explanations got a bit muddled in my last post -
so I am reiterating it here - sorry!
> > >As per history of the letter A_YAPAHALAA_AA, there is no
> > > mention of this composite in original "Varna
> > > Parichay- Part 2" by Iswarchandra Vidyasagar,
> > > -unanimously considered by bengalies the original
> > >alphabet of modern Bengali. This was probably added later to
> > >tranliterrate words like Academic from English.
And then Michael Everson wrote in reply:
> > This is not correct. For example, in Sanskrit and Bengali, we have
> > the word pratyeka 'each, every'. This is derived from the Sanskrit
> > root prati (expressing likeness or comparison) plus eka 'one'. In
> > Sanskrit orthography i + e becomes ye and is so written. Now in
> > Bengali this word also exists and in both languages what is written
> > is PA + VIRAMA + RA + TA + VIRAMA + YA + E + KA.
Michael, you are mistaken here, Anitra was referring to the composite
letter ' A_YAPAHALAA_AA' and not the composite letter sign
'YAPAHALAA_AA' which - yes - has been around for *quite some time*)
Viramas and vowels should not & do not mix in the Unicode encoding
scheme. That is why we have Vowel Signs.
E.g. The syllable 'KU' is semantically equivalent to a composite of 'Ka'
and the Full-Vowel letter 'U'.
It is encoded as 'Ka' + 'VowelSignU' in the Unicode scheme.
It could also be said that 'KU' can be encoded as 'Ka'+'Virama'+
'Full-Vowel letter U' In fact that is just the way it *is* done in some
existing input methods :- but that would not be in line with the Unicode
Indic encoding scheme, would it.
(Incidentally that is also why the example in TUS3.0, Chapter 9, page
214, Figure 9-3 ("Conjunct Formations"), example (4) is also wrong.
(references as previously discussed on this list many times before).
That example 'conjunct' is correctly encoded as Ra+'VowelSignVocalicR'
in Unicode and not as shown - perhaps you could see that it is corrected
This archive was generated by hypermail 2.1.5 : Sat Mar 01 2003 - 16:33:11 EST